Contact Us If you would like a quote on home, auto or business, click here. If you would like someone to call you back, scroll down and fill out our contact form below. Request Free Consultation Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.Name *Email *PhoneType of InsuranceType of Insurance*Auto InsuranceHome InsuranceBusiness InsuranceMessage *EmailSubmit Get In Touch We are local! 212 San Marco Avenue St. Augustine Florida 32084 contact@oldestcityinsurance.com Call us Today! (904)824-7283 Have a question about a specific coverage or general questions about your existing policy. Learn about important discounts you may be entitled to to help reduce your premium. Schedule and in-person meeting to review your existing policy.